If you're in BYU Writing 150H sections 122, 126, or 129 you're in the right place.


My name is Dr. SWILUA. (Pronounced "Swill-oo-ah") That's short for "She Who Is Like Unto Aphrodite." It's my official title, thanks.

Tuesday, October 5, 2010

McKay E's Response to "When Nice Ain't So Nice"

Reading Eloise Bell’s article “When Nice Ain’t So Nice” scared me. Each point she made about the use of “nice” in our society seemed to highlight everything I try to do. I have been described as your “overly nice person who does everything he can to help others.” I hate feeling angry or hurting others. I have never really paid attention to any feelings of anger or “dark side” tendency as she describes them, but I have had several people predict that one day my niceness will snap and I will become a mass murderer. This is obviously an extreme prediction, but I do worry that I may not be balanced emotionally. 
It is interesting that she should mention the high amount of pressure to be nice in today’s world. I never considered the fact that I would feel guilty if I didn’t live up to the “nice” standard, but looking back this is a legitimate point. In school I would always see other people do things that seemed so rude and obscene in my opinion, that I would never be seen doing...and this could easily be explained by the high “nice” standard I had been taught by my parents and the community that largely affected my upbringing. I would never want anyone seeing me talk back to people, or crying, or yelling at someone. I know that keeping my “nice” composure all the time ensures that people hold a high opinion of me and my personality. 
What if I have a “dark side” driven into hiding by the need to have such a positive image in society? What if I am slowly building up unvented anger and hostility that will some day explode and become apparent to everyone around me. I think I have a fear of being  mean to people. It is very probable that this fear of cruelty has forced me to ignore negative emotions at times in my life, although I never thought they would stay inside me forever...waiting to become expressed.
The biggest comfort I have facing this dire possible outcome in life is the fact that I have a family on this earth. I know Heavenly Father does everything for a reason and having a family unit on this earth is no different. It is reasonable for me to assume that your family is one place where you should always have someone you can talk to. I know that I have had several late night discussions about life with my parents, or my older brother, even more so now that I am in college. These moments of discussion allow me to express fears and doubts in a positive and constructive way. Talking it out, I know that emotional conflict is resolved and I am able to move on being “nice” without having to worry about have to face my anger the next day. I think forgiveness and repentance work the same way. I know I don’t have to worry about being overly nice and killing everyone someday because I can let go of everyday’s repressed anger or frustration by forgiving my fellow man and looking forward with love. 
While this good piece of news if comforting, it doesn’t put away Bell’s terrifying argument that society can be “too nice.” I am a living model of societies “Mr. Nice.” After reading this article I don’t feel like altering my lifestyle. I won’t change my nice ways and start openly expressing my anger to anyone how crosses my path, but I will be more conscious of my negative emotions and how I express or repress them. There is definitely a point where being “too nice” can be unhealthy. Hopefully I will be able to recognize that point before I cross the line.

6 comments:

  1. love your post. i agree with you- bell makes decent points but (to bring something from another post on the article) i think she is talking more about being fake or hypocritical. I like that you talk about not acting nice but being nice- you don't hide your anger, you postpone it until it can be released in a good way. good on ya!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yeah, I really don't nessicarily think that all forms of suppressing anger are attempts to wrangle with some giant, all consuming, inner beast. Honestly, I think that a lot of people on this earth are just CHILL! it doesn't matter if you have to sit at the back of the bus, or if you get jostled around. There isn't any point in making a scene! I really think that people are overly sensitive if anything. people should go with the flow. Yeah, in the event of something that i find to be a gross injustice I'll fight back. I've had my fair share of arguments, heated or not. I don't think that attempts to regulate behavior are completely based off some intense desire to fit some social "nice" mold. I think people behave rationally and they decide to fight or not based on what they think is going to bring them the most happiness. Yes, some people do try too hard to be nice, and I think that this is a plague for people,. and probably more so in the LDS church than in others, but I'm not sure I buy that it's some massive problem that is going to turn all mormons into 7 headed dragons that like to burn people's prized petunias and molest their children. I think the author went just a little bit overboard with her analysis.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I kind of understand your fear here, that maybe being nice is actually counterproductive... What I decided is that, instead of saying either "I will no longer be nice" or "I will ignore this essay and be nice," instead I will be nice, courteous, chivalrous, kind, and I will stand up for myself and for other people.
    In other words, I don't believe this essay attacks "nice" so much as it does "doormat." With that replacement, I am ok with just about everything she says.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I like your method of suppressing your anger. I think forgiving and looking forward with love is a more affective solution than screaming in a pillow or taking out anger in some other fashion.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think I can relate to being nice to people as a part of my persoality as well. It's not that I look for ways I can help others, it's just when you see an oppertunity it's like instinct to go help. I also want people to get a good impression of me no matter if I've known them for a long time or just pass them walking to class. I think society does affect some of the way we act as well. Although I am not openly mean to people, I struggle with talking behind their back and expressing things that bother me about them to other people. This is a horrible habit but I don't think I could ever be mean straight to their face. I'll have to repress these emotions and like you forgive and forget as well as look at the good qualities.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I think that lots of LDS people are like you. I also don't want to get mad at or hurt other people, since I had some pretty awful acquaintances throughout my life that were just HORRIBLE to me, and I never ever want to make someone else feel like I felt when I was around those people. I don't think you have to worry too much about suppressed anger eventually getting the best of you and turning you mean and nasty, however. I think that as members of the LDS church, it's natural to get even nicer as you come closer to Heavenly Father (which I hope we're all doing as we age) rather than turn meaner. I deal with my frustrations in the same way, though. I love to talk to my family, and even some of my close friends about what has been bothering me in life, and they usually help me feel a lot better about everything. It's a really useful method for cheering yourself up. :)

    ReplyDelete